Two Days on One Keyboard Dismiss Button
At the right end of the formatting bar above the keyboard there is a button that puts the keyboard away. I changed its color, swapped it for a check and swapped it back, put it in a square, shrank it, and grew it again. Two days later it is exactly the size I called too intense on day one.
When you write in fecit, a formatting bar appears above the keyboard. At its right end there is one button that puts the keyboard away. I spent two days on that one button.
From gray to blue
It used to be a light gray keyboard icon. It got lost among the formatting buttons and was hard to see. So I made it blue. Up to here it was simple.
To a check, and back
The same day, I tried a white check in a blue circle in that spot.
It didn’t look right. I tried it once more, and also brought back a check button in another place that I had removed that morning. All of them came out again.
There were two reasons.
- This button only puts the keyboard away. A check reads as “confirm”. On the screen where you create a task, you would think pressing it creates the task.
- In fecit, a check is the mark for a completed task. Two checks with different meanings on one screen are confusing.
So it went back to the keyboard icon. It draws exactly what happens, so even if the meaning isn’t strong, there is nothing to misread.
Into a square, then smaller
Later that day I changed the blue icon into a white icon inside a blue square. I first showed it at 30, the same size as the formatting buttons next to it.
It was more intense than I expected. So I shrank the square to 26 and the icon to 18. Now that it was a filled shape it looked stuck to the edge of the screen, so I widened the right margin from 8 to 12.
Bigger again
The next day I decided to make the icon a little bigger. 18 went up to 20.
Then I wondered how big the icon had been before the square, and looked it up. It was 24. It had shrunk all the way to 18 on its way into the square.
I decided to take it back up to 24. But a 24 icon does not fit in a 26 square. Only 1 of margin is left. So the square went up to 30 as well.
30 is the exact size I had shrunk the day before for being too intense.
After pulling the right margin in a little, from 12 to 10, it felt about right.
What I tried after that
I didn’t stop there, and tried two more things.
Is there an icon that says “done editing”? I asked Claude, and the candidates were the word “Done”, a return arrow, a down chevron, and a pencil with a check. Trying to say “finished” with a picture ends up back at the check, and I had closed that road the day before. I left it alone.
A slightly simpler keyboard icon. I asked Claude to reduce the dots inside the keyboard. With the top row cut to three dots, the preview apparently looked like a robot face: three dots and a space bar. I got a four-dot version, and went back to the original icon.
The result of two days
In numbers:
| Icon | Background | |
|---|---|---|
| At first | Gray, 24 | None |
| Blue | Blue, 24 | None |
| First square | White, 22 | Blue square, 30 |
| Shrunk | White, 18 | Blue square, 26 |
| Now | White, 24 | Blue square, 30 |
The icon is the size it started at, and the square is the size I once threw out. What changed in two days is the color, the background, and 2 of right margin.
I learned why the check doesn’t work only after putting it on the screen. And the 30 square: with a 22 icon I shrank it, with a 24 icon I kept it.
It was a fun dig in the wrong place.